Eosinophilic fasciitis, a disease also referred to as Shulman syndrome, is characterized by chronic inflammation of fasciae. Eosinophilia is present in most patients, but the precise etiology of this disorder is unknown.
Presentation
Patients who present with early stages of EF may show dermatological symptoms like erythema and edema that mainly affect trunk and proximal limbs. Acute symptom onset may be related to recent vigorous exercise or trauma [7]. Fasciitis doesn't occur until later stages of the disease and typically manifests in progressive thickening and induration of the skin, subsequent joint contracture and decreased mobility. Of note, "later" refers to a few days or weeks after symptom onset. While erythema and edema don't usually affect hands and feet, joint stiffness frequently affects articulations of distal limbs. In this context, carpal tunnel syndrome is sometimes observed. The latter is caused by compression of nerves by fibrotic tissues and provokes numbness and paresthesias in the affected hands. Pain, particularly myalgia and arthralgia, is often reported.
Despite their acute onset, symptoms progress slowly. Disease progress can best be evaluated after observation of skin changes. Initially, thickening and hardening of the skin may be accompanied by formation of grooves along the veins. Ultimately, large areas of skin may become very wrinkled, take on the appearance of orange peel or even resemble tree bark.
In general, symptoms manifest symmetrically, although cases of unilateral eosinophilic fasciitis have been reported [11].
Workup
Despite of acute symptom onset, several months may pass until EF is diagnosed. Due to unspecific symptoms and little awareness of this rare connective tissue disorders, many EF patients are misdiagnosed with systemic scleroderma, deep vein thrombosis and other diseases [7]. After physical examination, additional diagnostic measures like laboratory analyses of blood samples may be carried out - and should support a tentative diagnosis of EF - but only visualization of fasciae involvement by means of imaging techniques and histopathological examination of tissue samples are considered diagnostic.
With regards to the former, hemogram and blood biochemistry may reveal the following:
- Eosinophilia. Although elevated numbers of eosinophil granulocytes are measured in up to 90% of all EF patients, eosinophilia is not an exclusion criterion for this disease. Patients who present with typical clinical and histopathological alterations may be diagnosed with EF despite of an unaltered hemogram.
- Increase of proinflammatory parameters, prolonged erythrocyte sedimentation rate and hypergammaglobulinemia.
- Additional alterations of cell counts may be associated with underlying hematological disorders and require a specific workup.
Magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography scans are most frequently applied to assess the condition of subcutaneous tissues and muscles. Both techniques allow for visualization of fascial thickening and their results should be considered before deciding on a biopsy site. Tissue samples typically show fascial thickening, infiltration with lymphocytes, macrophages and eosinophils, and fibrosis. As fibrosis augments, inflammation subsides.
Non-invasive follow-ups based on diagnostic imaging will also permit to evaluate the patient's response to treatment.
Treatment
The standard treatment for EF consists in prolonged application of corticosteroids, e.g., prednisone, prednisolone or derivatives. Follow-ups should reveal softening of the skin as early as one month of therapy, although complete resolution may not occur until several months later. Blood counts often normalize within two months, but inflammatory parameters like erythrocyte sedimentation rate and globulin levels may not lower until various months after initiation of treatment. Although a variety of other drugs, mainly immunosuppressive compounds, has been administered to accelerate recovery or to treat persistent cases of fasciitis, there is no scientific evidence regarding their efficacy.
Physiotherapy should accompany drug treatment and aim at improving joint mobility and rebuilding muscle strength.
Surgery is generally not indicated, but may constitute an alternative treatment option in intractable cases of EF.
Prognosis
With regards to mortality, possibly underlying hematological disorders or malignancies largely determine the likelihood of a fatal outcome. And while EF is not considered a lethal disease, permanent restriction of joint mobility may constitute a considerable reduction of life quality. In a retrospective study analyzing the outcome of 88 EF cases, the following findings have been identified as unfavorable prognostic factors, i.e., as factors associated with higher risks of residual fibrosis:
- Morphea-like skin lesions
- Young age at onset
- Trunk involvement
- Histopathological evidence for dermal sclerosis
The relative importance of factors listed above seems to decrease top down [10].
Many patients may expect complete resolution of symptoms, although recovery may take months. Spontaneous resolution has been described.
Etiology
The etiology of EF is largely unknown. However, retrospective analysis of EF cases revealed prevalence rates of certain comorbidities that exceed those calculated for the general population. Due to the limited number of cases reported to date, coincidence cannot be excluded for all such findings. The following list of possible etiological factors contributing to EF should be interpreted keeping that limitation in mind.
- Hematological disorders associated with decreased or elevated cell counts of erythrocytes, granulocytes, lymphocytes and platelets have repeatedly been related with EF. Hemolytic anemia, thrombocytopenia, lymphoma and leukemia shall be mentioned as examples. See, for instance, references [4] [5].
- Because EF has not only been diagnosed in patients suffering from hematological malignancies but also in individuals with solid neoplasms, it has also been proposed to develop as paraneoplastic syndrome [5].
- EF has repeatedly been related with Borrelia burgdorferi infection. However, only a very small share of borreliosis patients develops EF and it is not clear which additional factors trigger the onset of fasciitis in patients infected with these spirochetes.
- Administration of distinct drugs has been reported to induce EF. In this context, L-tryptophan should be highlighted. This amino acid or traces of other compounds found in L-tryptophan formulations have been shown to induce eosinophilia myalgia syndrome, a disease characterized by progressive thickening and hardening of the skin and eosinophilia, amongst other symptoms [6]. The resemblance of clinical presentation of both disorders had researchers speculate that their etiology may be similar, too.
Epidemiology
EF is a rare disease and less than 300 cases have been reported to date [3]. Recently, a retrospective study has been published that includes case data of 63 EF patients [7]. According to this study, the vast majority of EF patients are Caucasians. However, this study has been conducted in the United States and may not be representative for other countries with larger populations of Blacks and Asians. The male-to-female ratio seems to approximate 1:2. Although precise values differ slightly, a female predominance had been reported before.
EF may manifest at any age.
While EF may be associated with significant morbidity, it is not a lethal disease. However, EF patients may suffer from additional pathologies like hematological disorders and solid neoplasms that considerably reduce their life expectancy.
Pathophysiology
EF results from an inflammatory process mainly involving fasciae. As has been described above, its triggers are not yet known. More light could be shed on the pathophysiological events following fascia infiltration with inflammatory cells.
Histopathological analysis revealed that lymphocytes and macrophages predominate in biopsy samples obtained from EF patients. Eosinophil granulocytes only account for minor shares of inflammatory infiltrates. With regards to macrophages, it has been shown that their precursors, peripheral blood mononuclear cells, release abnormally high amounts of proinflammatory cytokines interleukin-2 and interferon-γ as well as increased quantities of antiinflammatory cytokines interleukin-5 and interleukin-10 [8].
Although elevated levels of antiinflammatory cytokines may not explain fasciitis, interleukin-5 has been shown to activate eosinophil granulocytes, induces growth, maturation and differentiation of these cells. It also exerts chemotactic effects, which may explain infiltration of eosinophils into inflamed fasciae.
Additionally, elevated concentrations of transforming growth factor-β have been measured in serum samples of EF patients [9]. This cytokine causes fibroblast proliferation and production of extracellular matrix. Although it is probable that other factors contribute, transforming growth factor-β may partially account for progressive fibrosis of affected fasciae.
Prevention
No specific measures can be recommended to prevent EF.
Summary
Eosinophilic fasciitis (EF) is a rare, chronic inflammatory disease of unknown etiology. The same disease may also be referred to as diffuse eosinophilic fasciitis or Shulman syndrome, whereby the latter name was chosen in honor of Lawrence E. Shulman. This US-American physician first described the disease in 1975 [1].
The main characteristics of EF are erythema and edema of large parts of the skin, eosinophilia, and structural remodeling, thickening and funcio laesa of fasciae. Unspecific dermatological symptoms often precede fasciitis, but if blood samples are analyzed during early stages of the disease, elevated cell counts of eosinophil granulocytes are already detectable in most cases. Of note, eosinophilia is not an exclusion criterion for EF.
Fascia involvement manifests in progressive induration of the skin and soft tissues [2], symptoms that are easily confounded with cutaneous scleroderma. In fact, EF is sometimes also classified as a scleroderma-like disease. However, scleroderma patients commonly present with digital lesions while erythema and edema due to EF are usually limited to trunk and proximal limbs. Also, Raynaud's phenomenon is typical for scleroderma but not for EF. Even though these clinical differences may imply that a patient is suffering from EF rather than from scleroderma, a tentative diagnosis of this connective tissue disorder needs to be confirmed by application of diagnostic imaging and/or histopathological analysis of biopsy samples in order to demonstrate involvement of fasciae instead of the dermis. Fasciae infiltration of inflammatory cells, mainly lymphocytes and macrophages, can only be shown histopathologically. Magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography scans are the methods of choice to assess a possible involvement of internal organs, a finding often noted in systemic scleroderma but not in EF.
EF patients usually respond to corticosteroid treatment. If comorbidities are diagnosed that possibly contribute to the onset and progress of fasciitis, they should be treated accordingly. Non-curable underlying diseases often diminish the efficacy of immunosuppressive therapy and worsen the prognosis significantly. Several of such intractable cases have been reported and a variety of drugs has been administered to relieve EF-associated symptoms in these patients, but general recommendations cannot be given to this end.
Low incidence and prevalence rates - less than 300 cases have been reported to date [3] - complicate research regarding EF etiology, pathogenesis and causative treatment. To date, case reports are the main source of data and several hypotheses presented in this article or elsewhere require further validation.
Patient Information
Eosinophilic fasciitis (EF) is a rare connective tissue disorder characterized by reddening and swelling of large parts of the skin, elevated cell counts of eosinophil granulocytes, and structural remodeling, thickening and loss of function of fasciae.
Less than 300 cases have been reported to date, which is why knowledge regarding the disease' causes, progress and therapy is still rather limited.
Causes
Little is known about the causes of EF. Some EF patients also present hematological disorders, e.g., anemia, reduced amounts of platelets, increased numbers of lymphocytes and other white blood cells. Also, EF may be related with cancer, tick-borne borreliosis or ingestion of L-tryptophan. Few of these causal relations are supported by scientific evidence; they merely base on observations made in this little group of patients that have been diagnosed with EF.
Symptoms
Dermatological symptoms, e.g., reddening and swelling of the skin, often precede fasciitis. These symptoms are usually limited to trunk and proximal limbs, while hands and feet are generally spared. As the diseases progresses, the skin becomes increasingly thick and hard. This condition may even limit joint mobility.
If blood samples are analyzed, they typically reveal eosinophilia and imply inflammation.
Diagnosis
Clinical symptoms may easily be confounded with those of cutaneous scleroderma or other diseases. Thus, fasciae have to be visualized by means of magnetic resonance imaging or computed tomography scans and histopathological examination of tissue samples. Only if thickened, inflamed fasciae can be seen both from the outside and under the microscope, a patient may be diagnosed with EF.
Treatment
Most patients respond well to corticosteroid application. Symptoms may start to subside after about a month, but complete resolution may not be achieved until several months later.
Physiotherapy is helpful to regain joint mobility.
References
- Shulman LE. Diffuse fasciitis with eosinophilia: a new syndrome?. Trans Assoc Am Physicians. 1975; 88:70-86.
- Sène D. [Eosinophilic fasciitis (Shulman's disease): Diagnostic and therapeutic review]. Rev Med Interne. 2015; 36(11):738-745.
- Samona J. Orthopedic considerations with eosinophilic fasciitis: a case report and literature review. Case Rep Orthop. 2012; 2012:865360.
- Bachmeyer C, Monge M, Dhote R, Sanguina M, Aractingi S, Mougeot-Martin M. Eosinophilic fasciitis following idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, autoimmune hemolytic anemia and Hashimoto's disease. Dermatology. 1999; 199(3):282.
- Haddad H, Sundaram S, Magro C, Gergis U. Eosinophilic fasciitis as a paraneoplastic syndrome, a case report and review of the literature. Hematol Oncol Stem Cell Ther. 2014; 7(2):90-92.
- Dourmishev LA, Dourmishev AL. Activity of certain drugs in inducing of inflammatory myopathies with cutaneous manifestations. Expert Opin Drug Saf. 2008; 7(4):421-433.
- Wright NA, Mazori DR, Patel M, Merola JF, Femia AN, Vleugels RA. Epidemiology and Treatment of Eosinophilic Fasciitis: An Analysis of 63 Patients From 3 Tertiary Care Centers. JAMA Dermatol. 2016; 152(1):97-99.
- Viallard JF, Taupin JL, Ranchin V, Leng B, Pellegrin JL, Moreau JF. Analysis of leukemia inhibitory factor, type 1 and type 2 cytokine production in patients with eosinophilic fasciitis. J Rheumatol. 2001; 28(1):75-80.
- Dziadzio L, Kelly EA, Panzer SE, Jarjour N, Huttenlocher A. Cytokine abnormalities in a patient with eosinophilic fasciitis. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2003; 90(4):452-455.
- Endo Y, Tamura A, Matsushima Y, et al. Eosinophilic fasciitis: report of two cases and a systematic review of the literature dealing with clinical variables that predict outcome. Clin Rheumatol. 2007; 26(9):1445-1451.
- Danis R, Akbulut S, Altintas A, Ozmen S, Ozmen CA. Unusual presentation of eosinophilic fasciitis: two case reports and a review of the literature. J Med Case Rep. 2010; 4:46.